Chest of Colors forum

Posted: **26 Sep 2010, o 21:03**

https://www.games-workshop.com/gws/conte ... 6a&start=2

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 09:11**

Nice opinion article on the strange judging at the past GD: https://www.akaranseth.com/blog/10-years-back.htm

what do you guys think?

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 09:20**

hard to say anything constructive, as I've not been there and seen entries in flesh.
All I can say is - I'm not too surprised, have my own experience in judging GD PL with 2 guys from GW marketing department.

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 12:34**

That's not a good sign, makes me uneasy about entering GD next year then. Perhaps i'll opt to go to a different competition.

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 15:10**

I am a poor painter with very few exp. but I can see the difference between France, Spain and UK. Seems that GW new motto is "there`s no school like the old school"

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 15:13**

Well judging this type and any other type of art is always subjective, but i must say even do all the gw pictures are kind of wierd in quality, theres a drop in quality, but im looking foward to see the minis that werent winners.

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 15:51**

no news to anyone who attended GDs once or twice, but GD in most countries (all?) is like a giant lottery, less so on picking the top entries from the lower ones (but also there sometimes) and especially after they picked...say...the top 5 of a category. at a certain level most of the guys in the jury simply have no idea, because - sadly - they have no clue about showcase painting, because after they got hired, they stagnated their levels on what GW requires as far as painting goes from them and most likely don't spend a lot of time investigating into techniques and composition and all that.

EDIT: this post composition is horrible, but my head...I think you still get the point ^^

EDIT2: and yeah, I can see the argument "you dont have to be able to paint a picasso to judge a picasso" - yeah, but most critiques have at least some sort of expertise to show, like they studied that shit or are in the business for years, or... - most likely MOST judges (different from country to country) dont have that expertise - and then ofc you got the GW policy crap (sure it's their thing! and you got to be aware of it and then decide to enter on these terms or not) shadow over the whole thing.

EDIT3: so what do I want to say.... people should know by now what GDs are about and aproach the whole thing the way it is. don't take it too seriously and stay away if you expect a "fair" competition and can't deal with unexpected turnouts.

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 18:52**

My brother's entry:

Click to see full-sized image

Posted: **28 Sep 2010, o 22:41**

hi guys

some pics i took at the events...
was a nice day with a clearly disapointment for french guys

really good surprise with dark eldar

one thing was cool, seeing kornel kozak become a real heavy metal guy...he dreamed of it and it came true...congrats i'm really happy of your achievment !!!!

Click to see full-sized image

Posted: **29 Sep 2010, o 12:02**

thanks for the pics

how did you feel about the judging, Stefan? you made first cuts with your entries?

Chest of Colors forum

Games Day GD UK 2010

Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010

Re: Games Day GD UK 2010